My day job has been a relentless torrent of small talk the last few weeks.
And it’s glorious.
For an extrovert like me, good small talk is a renewable and infinite energy source. I readily admit I have the gift of gab, and I feed off of the social interchange.
What I find so appealing about small talk is the universality of the topics. The key is finding common ground and avoiding all of the potentially divisive subjects that cause your pulse to race, your face to flush and your blood pressure to rise.
The question I’ve been pondering recently is how small talk is different in the South, and, relatedly, how small talk is different in the New South. I have a few hypotheses.
We all know to avoid politics and religion in polite conversation with strangers, but what do you talk about? No matter where you live, the number one small talk topic is the weather. Lately, though, even the weather has gotten a little dicey because of the politics around climate change and global warming.
My favorite way to jump start a conversation about the weather goes something like this:
“Boy, how about this weather? Sure is hot/cold! It’s been really weird lately… on account of this here global warming.”
Not to give away all my secrets, but this is a real tell. The way they react gives me the cues I need to navigate the rest of the interaction. If it’s hot and they believe in climate change, they’ll say something like, “I can’t remember a time it’s been this hot this long.” If it’s hot and they don’t believe in climate change, they’ll respond with, “Yeah, but it’s always been hot down here in (insert Southern location here.)”
If it’s cold and they’re global warmingists, they’ll say, “We’re having fewer and fewer of these cold days. I remember when I was kid we’d have snow every other year.” And if they’re not believers in climate change they’ll come back with some variation of “Right! I need some of that global warming right about now because my heating bill is driving me to the poor house.”
See how useful small talk is?
I’m sure people of all regions discuss the weather when making small talk, but in the South it invariably leads to discussions of humidity. No one has had a better take on the topic lately than my hero, Landon. If you’re not familiar with his discourse on humidity, do yourself a favor and get caught up before coming back to finish up this post.
Family is usually a pretty safe topic as well. There are a number of landmines to avoid, however, and it can get messy real quick.
An innocent, “So, how’s your mommer ‘n ’em?” can head down some unexpected paths if she is in ill health, has recently passed, is involved in some family drama or recently appeared on “The Golden Batchelor.” I find it helpful to just stick with the general, “Tell me about your family.”
That allows my co-conversant to be selective with what they share and spare me the gory details. If someone asks me about my family, I don’t care if half of them are in the hospital and the other half in jail, I will find a bright spot to share to keep the dialogue moving.
“My oldest just made the honor roll, and Daddy got him a new truck,” works about every time. Feel free to borrow it.
Southerners also like to talk sports. Small talk, though, demands you stay away from arguments about college football. Rivalries are regionally specific, but I’ve found that living in Atlanta draws folks from all over. If you’re not careful, you’ll think you’re dealing with a “Roll Tide” person but they are 100% “War Eagle” and you’ve just made things really awkward if you guess wrong.
We’re in the best time of year now for safe sports small talk because just about everyone you meet in the South has awareness of if not outright affinity for the Braves. Whereas in olden times we could commiserate on their ineffectual play, nowadays we can relish their success. Nothing brings people together like shared admiration for Spencer Strider’s mustache. (Here’s hoping for a speedy return from elbow surgery.)
In the New South, traditional small talk topics are giving way to a new top three: The economy, traffic and the Internet/technology.
Like with the climate change discussion above, casual economic analysis among friends can quickly devolve into partisan rantings, but I observe that folks can’t help talking about prices these days. Politics enters the chat when it comes to assigning blame, but people these days always seem ready to bring up macroeconomic conditions regardless of their personal affairs.
Maybe it’s because I live in the Greater Atlanta Gridlock region, but traffic seems to be all anyone talks about anymore. If you live in the rural South you may talk about the time your uncle shut down main street when he drove his tractor to town and it stalled out at the caution light outside the Piggly Wiggly. Or someone from OTP (Outside the Perimeter of Atlanta) could bring up that time in ‘78 when they had to go to Atlanta to visit their cousin in the hospital.
“The traffic was terrible then, and I can imagine it’s only gotten worse.”
Pro tip: the economy conversation can slide easily into traffic if you use gas prices as a segue.
Finally, us New South people love to talk about our technology, especially if we do not understand it or know how to use it. If you’re engaging with someone of the digital generation, you can usually find some meme or gif that’s making the rounds you can share a laugh over. (Here’s one of my current favorites if you need inspiration.)
For those who are finding the adjustment to the smart phone more challenging, technology is still a relevant topic because you can share just how inept you are with it and what crazy thing it did “all on its own” the other day.
Tell me you haven’t recently had a conversation that sounded something like this:
“I need to get me a flip phone.”
“Oh, really? What seems to be the problem?”
“I was trying to take a picture of the fish I just caught, and I accidentally bought a 40-foot extension cord from Temu.”
This topic also works if you are proficient with tech. I still love to ask my tech savvy friends about “rendering speeds” and what to do when my computer’s “automatic cup holder” breaks.
Small talk is a gift, no matter where you live, and if you pay attention, you can keep up with the trends. It’s vital to our cohesiveness as a society, and it’s an undervalued skill.
If you find yourself stuck in a small talk conversation that’s going nowhere, you can use this blog to bail you out. Just say, “Hey, I read on the Internet the other day this deal called ‘New South Essays.’ You should check it out.”
Works every time.
What topics do you like to discuss when engaging with folks in small talk? Leave a comment below and help us navigate these fraught times.